How does scientific success relate to individual and organizational characteristics? Research data of a scientometric study of psychology researchers in the German-speaking countries.

Other Areas

Authors(s) / Creator(s)

Bauer, Hans
Schui, Gabriel
Krampen, Günter
von Eye, Alexander

Abstract

Associations of individual as well as organizational characteristics with research output were investigated for the population of psychology researchers in the German-speaking countries. Generating search-queries on literature databases, bibliometric data and individual as well as organizational characteristics were obtained and analyzed using Configural Frequency Analysis (CFA). Moreover, research output of the analyzed population as a whole was described to provide an anchor for monitoring and international comparison. Findings revealed that approximately 25 % of the population was publishing almost exclusively in German, only 5 % almost exclusively in English. Skewed distributions for publications and citations were found. Combination of female gender, small department size, and large quota of senior researchers was associated with particularly increased publication count. High publication count, large department size, and low quota of senior researchers were associated with increased citation count.
Interactions of individual as well as organizational characteristics with scientific success should be investigated further, e.g., by adopting various measures of organizational or gender diversity and tracing a population longitudinally.

Persistent Identifier

https://doi.org/10.5160/psychdata.brhs11me22

Year of Publication

2013

Funding

Citation

Bauer, H., Schui, G., Krampen, G. & von Eye, A. (2013). How does scientific success relate to individual and organizational characteristics? Research data of a scientometric study of psychology researchers in the German-speaking countries. (Version 1.0.0) [Data and Documentation]. Trier: Research Data Center at ZPID. https://doi.org/10.5160/psychdata.brhs11me22

Study Description

Research Questions/Hypotheses:

Research Design:

Search-queries on databases; single measurement

Measurement Instruments/Apparatus:

Personal data were collected in autumn 2010 using the online version of the Hogrefe psychology calendar (http://www.hogrefe.de/service/psychologie-kalender/). This calendar lists personnel employed at psychological institutes / departments of universities and other research centres.

Subjects were only considered if they…

  • were listed as employees at a category "A" institute (university institute that offers a degree in psychology as a major)
  • were not assigned to the employee category "C" (temporary research assistants)
  • had a doctorate (according to title information in the psychology calendar)
  • had graduated with a major in psychology (also determined by means of title information; when a generic title such as "Prof. Dr." was listed, a psychology major was assumed)

The generated population comprised 2134 subjects. The following subjects were excluded to ensure data quality:

  • subjects for whom no publications could be found
  • subjects with very common names (as publications and citations can not be reliably matched to these persons)

The final sample size obtained was N = 1742 (81.6 % of the population). A detailed description of the exclusion method is available from the authors upon request.

This final population was coded using name, sex and academic position title (doctorate vs. post-doctorate). The following organizational traits were used: the number of subjects from the population employed at each psychological institute as an indicator of institute size and the quotient of the number of post-doctorate and non-post-doctorate employees as an indicator for the ratio of experienced to young researchers.

Using the names of the population members, personal bibliometric parameters were collected from varying literature databases:

  • PSYNDEX: total number of publications, number of English publications
  • Web of Science (Science Citation Index Expanded + Social Science Citation Index): total number of citations, number of citations in English publications, total number of publications (the later value was solely used for validity control of the data and is not included in the dataset)

All of these queries took place between the beginning of August and the end of October 2011 and were not limited to a specific time period, meaning that the indicators pertain to the complete works of the investigated individuals.

Data Collection Method:

Search-queries on databases

Population:

Psychology researchers in the German-speaking countries

Survey Time Period:

Sample:

Complete sample

Gender Distribution:

35,1 % female subjects (n=612)
64,9 % male subjects (n=1130)

Age Distribution: Adults

Spatial Coverage (Country/Region/City): German-speaking countries (Germany, Austria, parts of Switzerland)

Subject Recruitment:

Sample Size:

1742 individuals

Return/Drop Out:

Valid data could be obtained for 81.6 % of the population.

brhs11me22_readme.txt
Text file - 3 KB
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Description of the files

brhs11me22_fd.txt
Text file - 126 KB
MD5: 2f7c3c0560b5945720af93be3378c5b4
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Research data file

brhs11me22_kb.txt
Text file - 6 KB
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: German codebook for the research data file brhs11me22_fd.txt

Position Name Label Valid Values Missing Values
1 CODE Nummerncode zur eindeutigen Kennzeichnung der Person 1000-5087 "Nummerncode zur Personenkennzeichnung" -1 "fehlend"
2 SEX Geschlecht 0 "weiblich" 1 "maennlich" -1 "fehlend"
3 RANK Akademischer Rang der Person 1 "habilitiert" 2 "promoviert" -1 "fehlend"
4 UNICODE Eindeutiger Zahlencode für Universität, an der die Person derzeitig tätig 1-58 "Zahlencode für Universität" -1 "fehlend"
5 ANZ_PROM_HABIL Anzahl Promovierte und Habilitierte, die an derzeitigem Institut der Person tätig (Abgeleitete Variable) 14-94 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
6 ANZ_PROM Anzahl Promovierte, die an derzeitigem Institut der Person tätig (Abgeleitete Variable) 3-50 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
7 ANZ_HABIL Anzahl Habilitierte, die an derzeitigem Institut der Person tätig (Abgeleitete Variable) 4-50 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
8 INST_GROESSE Großes Institut (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
9 HABIL_PRO_PROMOV Anzahl Habilitierte pro Promoviertem in Institut (Abgeleitete Variable) 0,25-4,0 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
10 H_PRO_P_DICHO Große Anzahl Habilitierte im Verhältnis zu Promovierten (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
11 LAND Land, in dem die Person derzeitig tätig 1 "Deutschland" 2 "Oesterreich" 3 "Schweiz" -1 "fehlend"
12 ANZ_ZITENGL Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus englischsprachigen Quellen in SCI/SSCI 0-2606 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
13 ANZ_ZITENGL_D Große Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus englischsprachigen Quellen in SCI/SSCI (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
14 ANZ_ZITGES Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus allen Quellen in SCI/SSCI 0-2743 "Anzahl" -99 "fehlend"
15 ANZ_ZITGES_D Große Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus allen Quellen in SCI/SSCI (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
16 ANT_ZITENGLGES Anteil Fremdzitationen englischsprachige an allen Quellen in SCI/SSCI (Abgeleitete Variable) 0,0-1,0 "Anteil" -1 "fehlend"
17 ANT_ZITENGLGES_D Hoher Anteil Fremdzitationen aus englischsprachigen an allen Quellen (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
18 ANZ_ZITNENGL Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus nicht englischsprachigen Quellen der "Psychologie"-Kategorien in SCI oder SSCI 0-677 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
19 ANZ_ZITNENGL_D Große Anzahl Fremdzitationen aus nicht englischsprachigen Quellen in SCI/SSCI (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
20 ANZ_PUBENGL Anzahl englischsprachige Publikationen in PSYNDEX, Datenbank des Leibniz-Zentrums für Psychologische Information und Dokumentation 0-205 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
21 ANZ_PUBENGL_D Große Anzahl englischsprachiger Publikationen in PSYNDEX (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
22 ANZ_PUBGES Anzahl aller Publikationen in PSYNDEX 1-920 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
23 ANZ_PUBGES_D Große Anzahl Publikationen in PSYNDEX (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
24 ANT_PUBENGLGES Anteil Publikationen englischsprachig an allen Publikationen in PSYNDEX (Abgeleitete Variable) 0,0-1,0 "Anteil" -1 "fehlend"
25 ANT_PUBENGLGES_D Hoher Anteil englischsprachige an allen Publikationen (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
26 ANZ_PUBNENGL Anzahl nicht englischsprachiger Publikationen in PSYNDEX 0-865 "Anzahl" -1 "fehlend"
27 ANZ_PUBNENGL_D Große Anzahl nicht englischsprachiger Publikationen in PSYNDEX (Abgeleitete Variable) 0 "nein" 1 "ja" -1 "fehlend"
Page 1 of 3
Items per page: 10 25 50
Further Reading
Krampen, G., Montada, L., Müller, M. M., & Schui, G. (2005). Internationalität und Internationalisierung der deutschsprachigen Psychologie. Göttingen: Hogrefe. PSYNDEX
Lotka, A. J. (1926). The frequency distribution of scientific productivity. Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences, 16, 317-323.
Moed, H. F., Glänzel, W. & Schmoch, U. (2004). Handbook of Quantitative Science and Technology Research: The Use of Publication and Patent Statistics in Studies of S & T Systems. Berlin: Springer.
Moed, H. F., Luwel, M., Houben, J. A., Spruyt, E., & Berghe, H. (1998). The effects of changes in the funding structure of the Flemish universities on their research capacity, productivity and impact during the 1980's and early 1990's. Scientometrics, 43, 231-255. doi:10.1007/BF02458409
Redner, S. (1998). How Popular is Your Paper? An Empirical Study of the Citation Distribution. The European Physical Journal, B4, 131-134.
von Eye, A., & Gutiérrez Peña, E. (2004). Configural frequency analysis: The search for extreme cells. Journal of Applied Statistics, 31, 981–997. doi:10.1080/0266476042000270545.
von Tunzelmann, N., Ranga, M., Martin, B., & Geuna, A. (2003). The effects of size on research performance: A SPRU Review. Brighton: University of Sussex.