Primary data on the study "Beauty and the busy mind"

Cognitive Psychology

Authors(s) / Creator(s)

Weigand, Rosalie
Jacobsen, Thomas

Abstract

Aesthetic experiences may be distinguished from other experiences by a cognitive mode of aesthetic processing that involves a concentration of working memory resources on the aesthetic stimulus. Because the capacity of working memory is limited, a trade-off between available resources and the aesthetic experience is obvious. To investigate the extent to which the intensity of the aesthetic experience is impaired when working memory capacity is stretched, an experience sampling study was conducted. Over a two-week period, 115 students reported on their aesthetic experiences. To survey working memory capacity, participants answered questions about their current cognitive load and any tasks they were currently performing. They were also asked if they had an aesthetic experience and how much they savored it. The data were analyzed using multilevel models. Higher working memory load was associated with fewer aesthetic experiences as well as reduced enjoyment of those experiences. Overall, other activities that require working memory capacity appear to conflict with aesthetic experiences in everyday life.

Persistent Identifier

https://doi.org/10.5160/psychdata.wdre20pr28

Year of Publication

2021

Funding

Citation

Weigand, R. & Jacobsen, T. (2021). Primary data on the study "Beauty and the busy mind" (Version 1.0.0) [Data and Documentation]. Trier: Research Data Center at ZPID. https://doi.org/10.5160/psychdata.wdre20pr28

Study Description

Research Questions/Hypotheses:

  1. Working memory load reduces the probability of occurrence of an aesthetic experience.
  2. Working memory load reduces the enjoyment of an aesthetic experience.
  3. Certain features of a concurrent task reduce the enjoyment of an aesthetic experience.

Research Design:

Fully standardised survey instrument; repeated measurements

Measurement Instruments/Apparatus:

A detailed description of the methods can be found in the associated publication.
We conducted an experience sampling study over a two-week period. Participants were asked to answer a short questionnaire via a smartphone app (“PIEL Survey”) 12 times a day during their individual waking hours. At each measurement time point, participants answered the question “Have you had an aesthetic experience since the last measurement time point?” on a binary yes/no scale. If they answered yes to the question, they were asked to name the content of the aesthetic experience by choosing from 8 categories. Regardless of whether they had an aesthetic experience, they were asked how they had spent the time since the last measurement time point (at home, outside, alone, in company). The variable “aesthetic enjoyment” was measured using three items (Schall, M., Goetz, T., Martiny, S. E., & Hall, N. C. (2017). It ain’t over ’til it’s over: The effect of task completion on the savoring of success. Motivation and Emotion, 41(1), 38-50.) was assessed on a 7-point Likert scale. Working memory capacity was answered using the item “I was engaged in a different task when I had the aesthetic experience” on a yes-no scale. If this item was answered in the affirmative, participants were asked about three task characteristics (challenging task, interesting task, important task, concentration on task) on a 5-point Likert scale. In addition, participants were asked about mean workload since the last measurement time point on a 7-point Likert scale.

Data Collection Method:

Experience sampling study using a smartphone app (“PIEL Survey”). Data transfer after completion of the study as an Excel file from the participant to the test management.

Population:

Students of psychology and educational sciences at Helmut Schmidt University

Survey Time Period:

Sample:

Convenience sample

Gender Distribution:

45 % female participants
55 % male participants


Age Distribution: 20-34 years

Spatial Coverage (Country/Region/City): Germany

Subject Recruitment:

Subjects were made aware of the study using a university email distribution list. They participated in exchange for partial fulfillment of course requirements. In order to increase the data response rate, a telephone call was made after one week in which the subjects were asked about the progress to date and possible problems.

Sample Size:

115 individuals

Return/Drop Out:

wdre20pr28_readme.txt
Text file - 3 KB
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Description of the files

wdre20pr28_pd_de.txt
Text file - 1419 KB
MD5: 5ce2fa6ebdacc6cd34cdc96c239cb7b6
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Primary data file (German version)

wdre20pr28_pd_en
Text file - 1418 KB
MD5: b83a180e093526b54c3ad5c53ba098ff
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Primary data file (English version)

wdre20pr28_kb_de.txt
Text file - 5 KB
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Codebook for the primary data file wdre20pr28_pd_de.txt

wdre20pr28_kb_en.txt
Text file - 5 KB
Sharing Level 1 (Scientific Use)
Description: Codebook for the primary data file wdre20pr28_pd_en.txt

Position Name Label Valid Values Missing Values
1 VP Versuchspersonennummer 1-116 "fortlaufende Versuchspersonennummer" 999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
2 STARTDATUM Bearbeitungsbeginn des Fragebogens Zeichenkette "Zeitpunkt der Berabeitungsbeginns" 999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
3 ENDDATUM Bearbeitungsende des Fragebogens Zeichenkette "Zeitpunkt des Bearbeitungsendes" 999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
4 ERFAHRUNG Erfahrung 0 "nein" 1 "ja" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
5 GENRE Genre 1 "Bildende Kunst" 2 "Musik" 3 "Darstellende Kunst" 4 "Literatur" 5 "Natur" 6 "Menschen" 7 "unbelebtes Objekt" 8 "Sonstiges" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
6 SONSTIGES Spezifikation von "Sonstiges" in der Variable "Genre" Zeichenkette "Spezifikation von 'Sonstiges' in der Variable 'Genre'" 999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
7 LATENZ Latenz 0-1200 "Latenz der ästhetischen Erfahrung in Minuten" 9999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
8 SAV1 Item 1 Savoring 1 "Überhaupt nicht" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Voll und ganz" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
9 SAV2 Item 2 Savoring 1 "Überhaupt nicht" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Voll und ganz" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
10 SAV3 Item 3 Savoring 1 "Überhaupt nicht" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Voll und ganz" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
11 AUFGABE Aufgabe 0 "nein" 1 "ja" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
12 HERAUSFORDERND herausfordernd 1 "lehne stark ab" 2 "lehne ab" 3 "teils/teils" 4 "stimme zu" 5 "stimme stark zu" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
13 INTERESSIERT interessiert 1 "lehne stark ab" 2 "lehne ab" 3 "teils/teils" 4 "stimme zu" 5 "stimme stark zu" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
14 KONZENTRIERT konzentriert 1 "lehne stark ab" 2 "lehne ab" 3 "teils/teils" 4 "stimme zu" 5 "stimme stark zu" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
15 WICHTIG wichtig 1 "lehne stark ab" 2 "lehne ab" 3 "teils/teils" 4 "stimme zu" 5 "stimme stark zu" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
16 AUSLASTUNG Auslastung 1 "Überhaupt nicht" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Voll und ganz" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
17 ZUHAUSE Zuhause 0 "nicht zuhause" 1 "zuhause" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
18 DRAUSSEN draussen 0 "nicht draussen" 1 "draussen" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
19 ALLEIN allein 0 "nicht allein" 1 "allein" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
20 GESELLSCHAFT Gesellschaft 0 "nicht in Gesellschaft" 1 "in Gesellschaft" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
21 GESCHLECHT Geschlecht 0 "männlich" 1 "weiblich" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
22 ALTER Alter 20-34 "Alter der Probanden in Jahren" 999 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
23 STUDIENGANG Studiengang 0 "Psychologie" 1 "Bildungs-/Erziehungswissenschaft" 9 "fehlender Wert: nicht spezifiziert"
Page 1 of 3
Items per page: 10 25 50
Position Name Label Valid Values Missing Values
1 VP Subject number 1-116 "consecutive subject number" 999 "missing value: not specified"
2 START_DATE Start date of the questionnaire String "Date of start of processing" 9999 "missing value: not specified"
3 END_DATE End date of the questionnaire String "Date of end of processing" 9999 "missing value: not specified"
4 EXPERIENCE Experience 0 "no" 1 "yes" 9 "missing value: not specified"
5 GENRE Genre 1 "Visual arts" 2 "Music" 3 "Performing arts" 4 "Literature" 5 "Nature" 6 "Human beings" 7 "Inanimate object" 8 "Other" 9 "missing value: not specified"
6 OTHER Specification of "other" in the variable "genre" String "Specification of 'Other' in variable 'Genre'" 999 "missing value: not specified"
7 LATENCY Latency 0-1200 "Latency of aesthetic experience in minutes" 9999 "missing value: not specified"
8 SAV1 Item 1 Savoring 1 "Not at all" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Full and complete" 9 "missing value: not specified"
9 SAV2 Item 2 Savoring 1 "Not at all" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Full and complete" 9 "missing value: not specified"
10 SAV3 Item 3 Savoring 1 "Not at all" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Full and complete" 9 "missing value: not specified"
11 TASK Task 0 "no" 1 "yes" 9 "missing value: not specified"
12 CHALLENGING challenging 1 "strongly disagree" 2 "dislike" 3 "partly/partly" 4 "agree" 5 "strongly agree" 9 "missing value: not specified"
13 INTERESTED INTERESTED 1 "strongly disagree" 2 "strongly disagree" 3 "partly/partly" 4 "agree" 5 "strongly agree" 9 "missing value: not specified"
14 CONCENTRATED focused 1 "strongly disagree" 2 "dislike" 3 "partly/partly" 4 "agree" 5 "strongly agree" 9 "missing value: not specified"
15 IMPORTANT important 1 "strongly disagree" 2 "disagree" 3 "partly/partly" 4 "agree" 5 "strongly agree" 9 "missing value: not specified"
16 UTILISATION Utilisation 1 "Not at all" 2 "" 3 "" 4 "" 5 "" 6 "" 7 "Full and complete" 9 "missing value: not specified"
17 AT_HOME At Home 0 "not at home" 1 "at home" 9 "missing value: not specified"
18 OUTSIDE Outside 0 "not outside" 1 "outside" 9 "missing value: not specified"
19 ALONE Alone 0 "not alone" 1 "alone" 9 "missing value: not specified"
20 COMPANY Company 0 "not in society" 1 "in company" 9 "missing value: not specified"
21 SEX Gender 0 "male" 1 "female" 9 "missing value: not specified"
22 AGE Age 20-34 "age of subjects in years" 999 "missing value: not specified"
23 STUDY_PROGRAM study peogram 0 "Psychology" 1 "Educational Sciences" 9 "missing value: not specified"
Page 1 of 3
Items per page: 10 25 50